Can You File ITR-1 If You Have Capital Gains? No – Here’s Why
- Rashmita Choudhary
- Jul 24
- 10 min read
The Income Tax Return (ITR) filing process in India can seem overwhelming, especially with the various forms designed to cater to different types of taxpayers. One of the most commonly used forms is ITR-1, also known as Sahaj, which is meant for individuals with straightforward tax situations. However, there are specific conditions that determine who can and cannot file this form, especially when it comes to income from capital gains. Let us explore what ITR-1 is, the restrictions on filing it with capital gains, and the reasons behind these restrictions. We’ll also cover the key updates for AY 2025-26 and provide a clear guide on who can file ITR-1, including a table that outlines the eligibility criteria.
Table of Contents
What Is ITR-1 (Sahaj) and Who Can File It?
ITR-1, also known as Sahaj, is one of the simplest and most commonly used Income Tax Return (ITR) forms in India. It is designed specifically for individual taxpayers who have a straightforward income profile and do not have complex financial situations that require additional schedules or documentation. The form is intended for people whose income is derived primarily from salaried sources, rental income, or other basic sources of income.
The ITR-1 form is streamlined for simplicity, allowing taxpayers with basic income types to file their returns without the need for complicated calculations or additional disclosures. Here is a more detailed breakdown of the categories of individuals who can use ITR-1:
Salaried Individuals
Salaried individuals are the most common users of ITR-1. If you earn income through salary or wages, you are eligible to file your return using this form, provided your total income is below ₹50 lakh. This category includes:
Individuals earning a salary: Employees who receive income from their employer, including any taxable allowances such as house rent allowance (HRA), special allowances, and bonuses.
Pensioners: Those who are receiving a pension from a government or private pension scheme. This includes both government and non-government pensioners who have no other significant sources of income.
Family Pensioners: Individuals receiving a family pension due to the death of a spouse or parent can also use ITR-1, provided their income is within the threshold of ₹50 lakh.
For salaried taxpayers, ITR-1 is convenient because the income details are typically available on Form 16, which is provided by the employer. It makes filing much easier as it reduces the need for multiple documents and calculations. The salary income, along with the deductions available under sections like 80C, 80D, and 10(13A) (for HRA), can be easily entered in this form.
Individuals with Income from One House Property
Another category eligible for ITR-1 is individuals who have income from one house property. This is common for people who either own a property or have rented one. The rental income from such property needs to be declared in the form, and the tax liability is calculated based on it. The form simplifies the process for individuals with rental income by directly including a section to declare this income, along with the deductions available under Section 24 for interest on home loan repayments (up to ₹2 lakh).
This category includes:
Rent Income: If you earn rental income from a residential property, commercial property, or any other type of real estate, and the income is not more than ₹50 lakh, you can file ITR-1.
Self-occupied Property: If the property is self-occupied (no income from it), you can still use ITR-1 as long as the income does not exceed ₹50 lakh. However, you must declare the "deemed rent" under Section 23(2) if you own more than one property.
For individuals with rental income, ITR-1 offers a simple method for reporting income and claiming deductions without the need for additional forms or complex calculations.
Income from Other Sources
Income from other sources includes a wide variety of income types, such as interest from savings accounts, fixed deposits, recurring deposits, or any other income that is not part of your salary, pension, or property income. This category is quite broad, and if your income from such sources is within the ₹50 lakh threshold, you can file using ITR-1.
Examples include:
Interest Income: Interest earned from savings accounts, fixed deposits, recurring deposits, or bonds.
Dividend Income: If you receive dividends from shares, mutual funds, or any other investment.
Other Sources: This could include lottery winnings, gifts from non-relatives (which are taxable), or income from a partnership firm (if it's not being filed separately).
While most individuals with income from these sources can use ITR-1, they must ensure that the income from all these sources, when combined with any other eligible income, does not exceed ₹50 lakh.
Key Features of ITR-1
The main advantage of ITR-1 lies in its simplicity. Designed to cater to individuals with straightforward financial profiles, it is free of complex schedules and doesn’t require extensive documentation. Key features of ITR-1 include:
Pre-filled Data: If you’ve filed your returns before or have a registered account with the Income Tax Department, many of your details (such as PAN, Aadhaar, previous year's income, etc.) will be pre-filled.
Simplified Deductions: Deductions under sections like 80C (for investments in PF, PPF, insurance, etc.), 80D (for health insurance), and 24(b) (for home loan interest) are easily accounted for in the form.
No Requirement for Business Income Disclosure: As ITR-1 is intended for individuals with income from salary, pension, and basic sources like rent and interest, individuals earning business or professional income must file a different form (e.g., ITR-3 or ITR-4).
Eligibility Criteria for ITR-1
To be eligible to file ITR-1, the following conditions must be met:
Total income must not exceed ₹50 lakh: This is the income limit for using ITR-1. If your income exceeds this threshold, you will need to use ITR-2 or another relevant form.
Sources of Income: Your income should be restricted to salary, one house property, and income from other sources (like interest). If you have income from business or profession, capital gains, or foreign income, you are ineligible to use ITR-1.
Not applicable to directors: If you are a director in a company, or if you have invested in unlisted shares or received income from a partnership, you cannot use ITR-1.
In conclusion, ITR-1 (Sahaj) is an excellent option for salaried individuals, pensioners, and those with simple income sources. It reduces the complexity of filing taxes and allows taxpayers to comply with their obligations easily. If you are eligible, using ITR-1 will save you time and effort while ensuring your return is filed accurately. However, it’s essential to carefully verify your income sources and ensure that they meet the criteria for ITR-1 before proceeding with the filing process.
Can You File ITR-1 If You Have Capital Gains?
ITR-1 is designed for individuals with basic income sources, but it does come with some restrictions regarding certain types of income. Specifically, if you have capital gains from the sale of assets such as stocks, bonds, or property, you cannot file ITR-1. Capital gains require a more detailed breakdown of the transaction, including the calculation of short-term or long-term capital gains, which is not suited for the simplicity of ITR-1.
If you have capital gains income, you will need to use ITR-2, which is designed for individuals who have income from multiple sources, including capital gains, foreign assets, or income from a business or profession.
Why These Restrictions?
The primary reason for the restriction on filing ITR-1 with capital gains is the complexity of reporting such income. Capital gains require more detailed disclosures and calculations than other types of income. When reporting capital gains, you must calculate whether the gains are short-term or long-term, apply the correct tax rate, and, in some cases, account for exemptions like those under Section 54 (for the sale of a residential property).
This level of detail makes ITR-1 unsuitable for taxpayers with capital gains. To ensure the accuracy and completeness of the tax return, individuals with capital gains are required to file using ITR-2, which provides the necessary space to disclose capital gains and related deductions or exemptions.
Key Updates for AY 2025-26
For AY 2025-26, there are a few significant updates to the ITR filing process that taxpayers should be aware of:
New Section 80TTA/80TTB Deductions: The government has introduced more comprehensive guidelines under sections 80TTA (for interest income) and 80TTB (for senior citizens). These deductions have been streamlined and updated for easier claims.
Revised Capital Gains Tax Rates: There are updates to the tax rates for short-term and long-term capital gains on certain assets, particularly for listed securities and bonds.
Updated Forms and New Tax Regimes: Taxpayers can now select between the old and new tax regimes, with specific implications for ITR-1 and other forms. The new tax regime offers a simplified approach but removes exemptions and deductions, which might affect those previously eligible for the ITR-1.
These updates affect the eligibility for filing ITR-1 and the information required, especially for individuals who have multiple income sources or complex financial situations.
Table: ITR-1 Eligibility with Capital Gains
Criteria | Eligible to File ITR-1 (Sahaj) |
Income Source | Salary or Pension; Income from one house property; Other sources (like interest) |
Capital Gains | Not eligible (must use ITR-2) |
Income Above ₹50 lakh | Not eligible (must use ITR-2) |
Foreign Income | Not eligible (must use ITR-2) |
Agricultural Income Above ₹5,000 | Not eligible (must use ITR-2) |
This table summarizes the main conditions under which you can or cannot file ITR-1, particularly with respect to capital gains and other restrictions for AY 2025-26.
Specific Questions Answered
Can I file ITR-1 if I have sold my residential property and earned capital gains?
No, you cannot file ITR-1 if you have sold a residential property and earned capital gains. You will need to use ITR-2 to report your capital gains and claim any exemptions under Section 54, if applicable.
If my total income is below ₹50 lakh, but I have capital gains, can I file ITR-1?
No, the amount of income does not matter if you have capital gains. If you have capital gains, you must file ITR-2, regardless of whether your total income exceeds ₹50 lakh.
Can I file ITR-1 if I have both salary income and income from a savings account?
Yes, as long as your total income does not exceed ₹50 lakh and your income is derived from salary and other sources (such as savings account interest), you can file ITR-1.
Conclusion
ITR-1 (Sahaj) is a simplified tax return form for individuals with straightforward income sources, but it comes with important restrictions, especially for those with capital gains. If you have income from capital gains, you must use ITR-2. As tax laws continue to evolve, staying updated on the eligibility criteria for each ITR form is crucial for accurate filing. The updates for AY 2025-26 further clarify these rules, and understanding them will help you avoid errors in your return. Always ensure you're using the correct form to streamline your tax filing process.
For anyone looking for assistance in tax filing, it is highly recommended to download theTaxBuddy mobile appfor a simplified, secure, and hassle-free experience.
Frequently Asked Question (FAQs)
Q1: Can I file ITR-1 if I have capital gains?
No, if you have capital gains, you cannot file ITR-1. ITR-1 is designed for individuals with simple income sources such as salary, pension, or income from one house property. Capital gains, especially long-term or short-term gains, require a more detailed return, and ITR-2 is the appropriate form for taxpayers with capital gains.
Q2: Why can’t I file ITR-1 if I have capital gains?
ITR-1 is meant for individuals with income from salary, one house property, and other straightforward sources. Capital gains require additional disclosures and calculations, including details about the sale of assets, dates of purchase and sale, exemptions under Sections 54, 54F, etc., making ITR-2 a more suitable choice for taxpayers with such income.
Q3: What kind of capital gains are covered by ITR-2?
ITR-2 is the correct form for both long-term and short-term capital gains. These could arise from the sale of assets like stocks, bonds, mutual funds, or real estate. The form allows taxpayers to report their capital gains, apply exemptions if eligible, and calculate taxes accordingly.
Q4: What is the difference between ITR-1 and ITR-2?
ITR-1 is for individuals with simple income streams, while ITR-2 is for individuals who earn income from more complex sources such as capital gains, multiple house properties, or income from foreign assets. ITR-2 allows detailed disclosures necessary for reporting capital gains, making it ideal for taxpayers with such income.
Q5: Do I need to file ITR-2 if I have only short-term capital gains?
Yes, even if you have only short-term capital gains, you need to file ITR-2. This form is required to report any kind of capital gain, whether long-term or short-term, and allows for the accurate calculation and reporting of the gains along with any taxes owed.
Q6: What details do I need to provide for capital gains in ITR-2?
For capital gains in ITR-2, you need to provide details such as the nature of the asset (e.g., property, stocks, bonds), the date of purchase and sale, the sale price, and the acquisition cost. Additionally, you may need to claim exemptions under relevant sections like Section 54, if applicable, and calculate your net taxable capital gains.
Q7: Can I claim exemptions on capital gains when filing ITR-2?
Yes, you can claim exemptions on capital gains when filing ITR-2. For example, if you sell a property and invest the proceeds in another property, you may be eligible for exemptions under Section 54 of the Income Tax Act. ITR-2 provides a section for claiming such exemptions and reducing your taxable capital gains.
Q8: What are the documents required for filing ITR-2 with capital gains?
When filing ITR-2 with capital gains, you will need documents such as proof of the purchase and sale of assets (e.g., sale deed, share purchase agreement), statements of capital gains from mutual funds or stocks, and details of exemptions claimed (e.g., purchase receipts for new property if claiming Section 54 benefits).
Q9: What happens if I file ITR-1 with capital gains?
If you file ITR-1 with capital gains, your return will be rejected by the Income Tax Department. Since ITR-1 does not support capital gains, the department will ask you to file the correct form (ITR-2). Additionally, any discrepancies may lead to penalties for incorrect filing.
Q10: Can I file ITR-2 for both salary income and capital gains?
Yes, you can file ITR-2 if you have income from salary as well as capital gains. ITR-2 is suitable for individuals who have income from multiple sources, including salary, capital gains, multiple house properties, and income from foreign assets.
Q11: Is there any difference in the tax treatment of long-term and short-term capital gains in ITR-2?
Yes, there is a difference in the tax treatment of long-term and short-term capital gains in ITR-2. Short-term capital gains (STCG) are generally taxed at a higher rate than long-term capital gains (LTCG). For instance, STCG from stocks is taxed at 15%, while LTCG is taxed at 10% if the gains exceed ₹1 lakh in a financial year. ITR-2 allows you to report both types of gains separately and apply the respective tax rates.
Q12: Can I file ITR-2 if I have capital gains but don’t need to claim exemptions?
Yes, you can file ITR-2 even if you do not need to claim exemptions. The form is designed to report capital gains, whether or not exemptions are claimed. If you have capital gains but do not qualify for any exemptions, you can still file ITR-2 to report the gains and pay taxes accordingly.
Comments