HRA vs. Home Loan: Which Saves More Tax in Your Case?
- Farheen Mukadam
- Sep 12
- 8 min read
Taxpayers in India are always on the lookout for ways to minimize their tax liabilities. Two common tax-saving mechanisms are the House Rent Allowance (HRA) exemption and Home Loan tax benefits. Both offer distinct advantages depending on an individual's situation. HRA helps salaried employees save taxes on the rent they pay, while home loan tax benefits provide deductions on both principal repayment and interest. However, the question often arises: which one is better? Understanding how each benefit works, and how they compare, is essential for making an informed decision. Let us explore both HRA and home loan tax benefitsin detail, compare their effectiveness, and help you determine which one can potentially save you more on taxes.
Table of Contents
Understanding HRA Tax Exemption
House Rent Allowance (HRA) is a component of a salary package that helps employees cover the rent they pay for their accommodation. The amount of HRA an employee receives is taxable, but the Income Tax Act provides a way to exempt a portion of it, making it a valuable tax-saving tool.
Under Section 10(13A) of the Income Tax Act, HRA is exempt from tax, but the exemption is subject to certain conditions. The amount of exemption is determined by the following factors:
Actual HRA received: The amount of HRA an employee receives forms the basis for the exemption.
Rent paid: The rent paid by the employee must exceed 10% of their salary.
Salary: This includes basic salary, dearness allowance, and any other allowances that form part of the salary.
Location of the rented property: If the employee resides in a metro city (Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata, or Chennai), they can claim a higher exemption.
The exemption is calculated using the least of the following:
Actual HRA received
Rent paid in excess of 10% of salary
50% of salary (for metro cities) or 40% of salary (for non-metro cities)
By properly claiming HRA, an employee can significantly reduce their taxable income.
Understanding Home Loan Tax Benefits
Home loan tax benefits are available underSections 80C and 24(b) of the Income Tax Act. These benefits provide substantial deductions for taxpayers who have taken loans to purchase, construct, or renovate a house.
Principal Repayment under Section 80C: The repayment of the principal amount on a home loan qualifies for a deduction of up to ₹1.5 lakh per year under Section 80C. This deduction is available to all individuals, regardless of whether the property is self-occupied or let out. Additionally, the amount paid towards stamp duty and registration fees also qualifies for this deduction.
Interest Payment under Section 24(b): Section 24(b) offers a deduction of up to ₹2 lakh per year on the interest paid on home loans. This deduction is available for loans taken for purchasing, constructing, or renovating a self-occupied property. For let-out properties, there is no cap on the interest deduction, and the full amount can be claimed as a deduction.
These combined deductions can help reduce your taxable income significantly, especially for those who are paying substantial interest on their home loans. Home loan tax benefits are one of the most effective ways for individuals to save taxes over the long term.
Quick Comparison: HRA vs. Home Loan Tax Benefits
HRA and home loan tax benefits both provide substantial relief, but they cater to different situations:
HRA: Available only to salaried individuals who are paying rent. It is dependent on the rent paid, the employee's salary, and the location of the rented property. It’s ideal for individuals who live in rented accommodations, especially those in metro cities where the exemptions can be higher.
Home Loan Tax Benefits: Available to individuals who have taken a home loan for purchasing, constructing, or renovating a property. These benefits allow for deductions on both the principal repayment (up to ₹1.5 lakh) and interest paid (up to ₹2 lakh for self-occupied properties). This is more beneficial for those who own a property and are repaying a home loan.
In essence, if you are paying rent and receiving HRA, that offers a significant benefit. On the other hand, if you own a home and are repaying a loan, the home loan tax benefits could provide even more savings in the long run.
Which Saves More Tax: HRA or Home Loan?
Determining whether HRA or home loan tax benefits save more tax depends on your unique financial situation.
If you are a tenant: If you're paying rent and receiving HRA, the tax savings from HRA could be more immediate and straightforward, especially if you live in a high-rent area like a metro city. However, the amount of savings will depend on your salary and the rent you pay.
If you own a home: The home loan tax benefits tend to provide more significant long-term savings, especially if you're repaying substantial interest on the loan. These benefits not only provide immediate tax savings on principal and interest but also contribute to building equity in your property.
In the long run, home loan tax benefits may offer more substantial savings, especially if you are paying a large amount of interest. For those paying substantial rent, however, HRA can provide quicker relief.
Latest News & 2025 Budget Highlights
The Union Budget for 2025 included several proposals that impact both HRA and home loan tax benefits. For instance, there may be changes in the tax slabs or the limit of tax exemptions available under Sections 10(13A) and 80C. As of now, the HRA exemption and home loan interest deductions remain largely unchanged, but the government continues to discuss improvements to ensure more individuals can benefit from these exemptions.
The government's focus on increasing housing affordability may also lead to more favorable tax benefits for home buyers, particularly in terms of deductions on interest payments for affordable housing loans. Any such changes would make home loan tax benefits even more advantageous, especially for first-time homebuyers.
Conclusion
Both House Rent Allowance (HRA) and Home Loan Tax Benefits are excellent tools for reducing taxable income, and the choice between the two depends largely on your living arrangements and financial goals. While HRA is ideal for those living in rented properties, home loan tax benefits provide greater long-term savings for property owners. Each has its advantages, and in some cases, taxpayers may even benefit from both. It’s important to evaluate your own financial situation to understand which option saves more tax for you. Always consult a tax expert or use a platform like theTaxBuddy mobile appfor personalized advice and efficient tax filing.
FAQs
Q1: Can I claim both HRA and home loan benefits?
Yes, you can claim both House Rent Allowance (HRA) and home loan benefits simultaneously if you meet the eligibility conditions for each. To claim HRA, you must be paying rent and receiving HRA as part of your salary. For home loan benefits, you can claim deductions on both the principal and interest paid for a property you own, even if you are living in a rented house. However, you cannot claim both for the same property. If you own a home and live in it, you can’t claim HRA for that property but can claim home loan deductions.
Q2: How much HRA can I claim?
The amount of HRA you can claim depends on three factors:
Actual HRA received from your employer
Rent paid minus 10% of your salary
50% of your salary (for metro cities) or 40% (for non-metro cities)
You can claim the least of these three amounts as your HRA exemption under Section 10(13A).
Q3: Can I claim home loan benefits for a property that is not self-occupied?
Yes, you can claim home loan benefits on a property that is not self-occupied, as long as the property is let out. Under Section 24(b), you can claim unlimited deductions for the interest paid on the loan. The principal repayment can be claimed under Section 80C, up to a maximum of ₹1.5 lakh per year. The benefits are the same for rented properties as for self-occupied properties, with the main difference being the taxability of rental income.
Q4: What if my employer doesn’t provide HRA?
If your employer does not provide HRA but you are paying rent, you can still claim a deduction under Section 80GG. This deduction allows individuals who are not receiving HRA to claim deductions for rent paid, subject to certain conditions like income thresholds and the fact that the taxpayer should not own any residential property in their name.
Q5: Can I claim tax benefits on a home loan if I’m renting out the property?
Yes, you can claim tax benefits on a home loan for a property that you are renting out. The interest paid on the home loan is deductible under Section 24(b), and you can also claim principal repayment under Section 80C, up to the respective limits. In case of rental income, you would need to declare the rental income, but the associated home loan interest can be claimed as a deduction, which might reduce your taxable income.
Q6: Can I claim both HRA and home loan deductions for the same property?
No, you cannot claim both HRA and home loan deductions for the same property. If you own the property, you cannot claim HRA for the same house even if you are paying rent. HRA can only be claimed if you are paying rent for accommodation that is not owned by you.
Q7: Is there a cap on the total amount of home loan benefits?
Yes, there is a cap on the total amount of home loan benefits. Under Section 80C, the principal repayment is capped at ₹1.5 lakh per year. For interest paid on a home loan, the deduction under Section 24(b) is capped at ₹2 lakh per year for a self-occupied property. For a let-out property, there is no upper limit for interest deduction, but rental income must be declared, and the expenses should be supported by proper documentation.
Q8: Can I claim HRA if I own a house?
No, you cannot claim HRA if you own the property in which you live. HRA is only eligible when you are paying rent for accommodation you do not own. If you own a home, you cannot claim HRA for that property. However, if you own a second house and are renting it out, you can claim deductions on the home loan interest for the second house.
Q9: How can I maximize my tax savings using HRA and home loan deductions?
To maximize tax savings, you should ensure that you are effectively utilizing both HRA and home loan benefits. If you live in rented accommodation, claiming HRA will provide tax relief. If you have a home loan, claiming deductions on the principal repayment under Section 80C and the interest under Section 24(b) will also reduce your taxable income. Keeping proper documentation, such as rent receipts and home loan repayment certificates, is essential for maximizing your claims. Additionally, reviewing your options annually and consulting a tax expert can help ensure you’re optimizing your deductions.
Q10: Does the 2025 budget propose any changes to HRA or home loan benefits?
The 2025 budget may introduce updates or changes to HRA and home loan benefits, especially for first-time homebuyers or individuals in affordable housing schemes. While details will be clear once the budget is announced, there might be revisions in the limit for home loan deductions or new exemptions. It's important to stay updated on the latest tax proposals and changes that might benefit taxpayers claiming these deductions.
Q11: Can I apply for tax deductions on home loans for both the interest and principal?
Yes, you can apply for tax deductions on both the interest and principal components of your home loan. The interest on the home loan is deductible under Section 24(b), up to ₹2 lakh for a self-occupied property. The principal repayment is eligible for deduction under Section 80C, up to ₹1.5 lakh. Together, these deductions can significantly reduce your taxable income.
Q12: How do I choose between claiming HRA or home loan deductions?
The decision to claim HRA or home loan deductions depends on your specific living and financial situation. If you live in rented accommodation and receive HRA, you can claim the HRA deduction. If you own a home and are repaying a loan, you can claim the home loan deduction. For a property you own and live in, the home loan deduction is more beneficial. However, if you are renting and receiving HRA, claiming the HRA deduction is the better option. You cannot claim both for the same property, so evaluating your living situation will guide the choice.
Comments