A Complete Guide to Handling Defective Return Notices (Section 139(9)) with TaxBuddy
- Rajesh Kumar Kar
- Dec 8
- 10 min read
Defective return notices under Section 139(9) are issued when an income tax return contains missing information, incorrect details, or mismatches that prevent accurate processing by the Income Tax Department. These defects often involve incorrect bank account entries, wrong ITR forms, unreported income, or discrepancies with AIS/TIS and Form 26AS. The notice outlines the error and provides a window to correct and resubmit the return. Resolving these issues quickly helps avoid refund delays and ensures the return is treated as valid. Platforms like TaxBuddy play a crucial role by helping taxpayers diagnose the exact defect and correct the return efficiently.
Table of Contents
Why a Return Becomes Defective: Common Errors and Missing Details
How to Respond to a Defective Return Notice (Section 139(9))
Is Bank Account Mismatch a Major Reason for Defective Returns?
How to Update Bank Details When Rectifying a Defective Return
Impact of NRE, NRO, and Savings Accounts on Section 139(9) Compliance
Can Opening a New Bank Account Cause a Defective Return Notice?
What Is a Defective Return Notice Under Section 139(9)?
A defective return notice under Section 139(9) is issued when an income tax return contains errors, incomplete information, or inconsistencies that prevent accurate processing by the Income Tax Department. These notices commonly highlight issues like mismatched income details, incorrect bank account numbers, wrong ITR form usage, or missing mandatory schedules. The taxpayer is provided a defined window—usually 15 days—to correct and resubmit the return. Rectification ensures the return is treated as valid, processed smoothly, and eligible for refunds. In recent years, an increasing number of defective notices relate specifically to bank detail inaccuracies and data mismatches with AIS, TIS, or Form 26AS.
Why a Return Becomes Defective: Common Errors and Missing Details
Defective returns often stem from missing, inaccurate, or inconsistent information. Among the most frequent causes are incomplete bank account details, wrong IFSC codes, and failure to mark the primary refund account. Income mismatches between the return and AIS/TIS or Form 26AS also generate defects. Incorrect ITR selection—such as filing ITR-1 instead of ITR-2 for capital gains—or missing schedules related to business income, foreign assets, or deductions can trigger a notice. Additional issues include unreported TDS entries, omitted tax payment details, and failure to verify the ITR within the permitted timeframe. Each of these errors prevents the return from being processed as filed.
How to Respond to a Defective Return Notice (Section 139(9))
Responding to a defective return notice requires reviewing the reason specified in the communication, usually available under the “e-Proceedings” or “View Notices” section of the Income Tax portal. Once the defect code and explanation are noted, the next step is to open the latest ITR utility corresponding to the assessment year. The identified error must be corrected—whether related to income reporting, bank details, TDS entries, or schedule omissions. After correction, the updated ITR is uploaded under the option “Response to Notice u/s 139(9),” and verification is completed via Aadhaar OTP, EVC, or net banking. Timely action prevents the return from being treated as invalid.
Correcting Bank Account Errors in Defective Returns
Bank detail errors are among the leading triggers of defective return notices. Corrections typically involve updating the account number, IFSC, account type, or refund-eligible account status. The revised ITR utility allows editing these details within the “Bank Accounts” section. All active accounts linked to the PAN must be accurately listed. After entering correct details, one account must be marked as the preferred account for receiving refunds. Any mismatch between account details in the return and data validated through the banking network can delay processing. Accurate corrections ensure smooth refund issuance and compliance with verification checks.
Is Bank Account Mismatch a Major Reason for Defective Returns?
Yes. A significant number of defective return notices arise due to inaccurate or outdated bank details. Incorrect IFSC codes, wrong account numbers, closed accounts still listed as active, or missing account entries often prompt a defect code under Section 139(9). Refund processing is directly tied to accurate bank details, making these errors particularly important. For many taxpayers—including NRIs—incorrect categorisation of account types (such as marking NRE accounts as savings accounts) also contributes to defects. Ensuring complete and validated bank details reduces the likelihood of receiving a defective notice.
How to Update Bank Details When Rectifying a Defective Return
Bank details are updated inside the revised ITR form during the correction process. After opening the latest utility, the “Bank Account” tab allows entering or modifying the account number, account type, IFSC code, and account status. The preferred refund account must be selected carefully. Once updated, the return is validated through the utility and uploaded as a response to the notice. Verification must be completed after submission. Correcting these details ensures the Income Tax Department can match the account with the PAN and process refunds without interruptions.
Impact of NRE, NRO, and Savings Accounts on Section 139(9) Compliance
Bank account type plays an important role in the validation of returns, especially for NRIs. Incorrect classification of NRE or NRO accounts may create mismatches during backend verification, leading to defective notices. NRE accounts typically cannot receive certain types of refunds, while NRO accounts are considered compliant for taxable receipts. Savings accounts linked to resident PANs must reflect accurate details and proper KYC. Ensuring that account types align with residential status and the nature of income helps avoid defective return notices associated with compliance mismatches.
Can Opening a New Bank Account Cause a Defective Return Notice?
Opening a new bank account after filing an ITR is not an issue by itself; however, failing to update this information when responding to a defective return notice can lead to refund rejections or delays. If the defective notice relates to bank information or refund account validation, the newly opened account must be added to the ITR before re-submission. The preferred account for refunds must be re-selected during the correction. Providing complete and updated details ensures the corrected return is processed without complications.
How TaxBuddy Helps Fix Defective Return Notices Quickly
TaxBuddy simplifies the process of resolving defective return notices through automated checks and expert-driven guidance. Its system identifies missing or inaccurate details by comparing the filed ITR with AIS/TIS, Form 26AS, and bank validations. Users receive clear, step-wise recommendations that highlight the exact defect code and the specific fields requiring correction. TaxBuddy’s automated modules detect bank detail mismatches, missing schedules, and incorrect ITR selection, ensuring that the revised return meets all compliance requirements. This streamlined assistance reduces errors and accelerates notice resolution.
Consequences of Not Rectifying a Defective Return on Time
Failure to rectify a defective return within the permitted timeframe may result in the return being treated as invalid. An invalid return is considered as not filed, leading to loss of refunds, carry-forward benefits, and certain deductions. It may also result in late filing penalties if a fresh return must be filed after the deadline. In some cases, incorrect or unrevised returns can be taken up for scrutiny. Although the Assessing Officer has the discretion to condone delays, relying on condonation is uncertain. Timely correction ensures uninterrupted processing and compliance.
Final Checklist Before Resubmitting the Corrected ITR
• All bank accounts updated with correct account number, IFSC, and account status • Primary refund account correctly selected • Income entries aligned with AIS, TIS, and Form 26AS • Correct ITR form selected for the income profile • All applicable schedules completed, especially capital gains, business income, and deductions • TDS entries verified and matched with Form 26AS • Tax payments (advance tax, self-assessment tax) accurately reflected • Declaration and verification completed before submission • Response uploaded under “Notice u/s 139(9)” instead of normal filing • Return re-verified using the selected verification method
Conclusion
Timely correction of a defective return notice under Section 139(9) ensures smooth processing of the income tax return and uninterrupted refund flow. Most defects arise from inaccurate bank details, wrong ITR form usage, or mismatches with AIS/TIS. A structured approach to reviewing defects and resubmitting the corrected return prevents the return from being marked invalid. Professional support platforms like TaxBuddy make this process more reliable by identifying errors instantly and offering guided corrections that reduce compliance risks. For anyone looking for assistance in tax filing, it is highly recommended to download the TaxBuddy mobile app for a simplified, secure, and hassle-free experience.
FAQs
Q. Does TaxBuddy offer both self-filing and expert-assisted plans for ITR filing, or only expert-assisted options? TaxBuddy provides two structured filing experiences to support different types of taxpayers. The self-filing plan is designed for those comfortable navigating the ITR on their own but who still want AI-backed checks to reduce filing errors. It automatically pulls data fromForm 16, PAN, and AIS/TIS to pre-fill important fields, minimizing manual input and reducing mismatches that often lead to defective return notices. The expert-assisted plan goes further, connecting users with trained tax professionals who review the entire filing, correct errors, ensure the return aligns with statutory requirements, and handle submission. Both plans can be used to correct defective returns issued under Section 139(9), ensuring accuracy and compliance.
Q. Which is the best site to file ITR? The ideal platform depends on the complexity of the taxpayer’s income and comfort level with tax forms. The Income Tax Department’s official portal is the standard filing platform, but it requires careful data entry and independent validation of details. Many taxpayers prefer using platforms like TaxBuddy because they offer automated data extraction, advanced error detection, and guided assistance. These features reduce the chances of mismatches with AIS/TIS or Form 26AS and help avoid common issues that trigger defective return notices. For those looking for convenience, accuracy, and professional oversight, TaxBuddy is considered one of the most reliable platforms.
Q. Where to file an income tax return? An income tax return can be filed either on the official Income Tax Department e-Filing portal or through trusted tax platforms such as TaxBuddy. The government portal provides direct access to filing utilities and supports all forms, but requires manual entry. Platforms like TaxBuddy enhance the experience by offering pre-filled data, automatic validation, and expert review. This makes the filing process smoother and reduces the risk of errors that could lead to Section 139(9) defective return notices.
Q. What triggers a defective return notice under Section 139(9)? A defective return notice is triggered when the Income Tax Department identifies inconsistencies or missing information in an ITR that make it impossible to process. Common triggers include mismatches between reported income and AIS/TIS or Form 26AS, incorrect bank details, wrong ITR form selection, or omission of mandatory schedules such as capital gains, business income, or deductions. Missing tax payment details, incorrect TDS entries, and unverified ITRs also frequently lead to defective notices. Each defect indicates that the return is incomplete or factually inconsistent, requiring correction.
Q. How long is the response window for a defective return? The standard response window is 15 days from the date the notice is issued. This timeline is provided under Section 139(9) to ensure timely correction of defects so that processing is not delayed. If the taxpayer believes more time is needed, an extension may be requested from the Assessing Officer. Approval is discretionary, but genuine reasons such as technical issues, form mismatches, or missing documents are generally considered.
Q. Can a wrong ITR form selection cause a defective notice? Yes. Incorrect ITR form selection is one of the most common reasons for receiving a defective return notice. For example, filing ITR-1 despite having capital gains, foreign assets, or business income automatically makes the return defective because the relevant schedules are missing. Similarly, choosing a form that does not support the taxpayer’s income type or deductions leads to inconsistencies between reported data and statutory requirements. Using the correct form eliminates these discrepancies and ensures smooth processing.
Q. Are bank account issues the most common cause of defective returns? Bank account discrepancies are among the leading contributors to defective return notices. Errors such as wrong account numbers, outdated IFSC codes, closed accounts, or missing bank details can prevent refund validation or cause backend mismatches during processing. For NRIs, incorrect classification of NRE/NRO accounts can trigger additional compliance flags. Ensuring accurate, up-to-date, and complete bank information is one of the most effective ways to avoid defective notices.
Q. Can defective return issues impact refunds? Yes. A defective return directly impacts the processing of refunds. Until the defects are corrected and the revised return is verified, the Income Tax Department will not issue any refund associated with the original return. If bank details are inaccurate, even a corrected return may face refund delays. In some cases, refunds are rejected entirely until the bank information is validated. Timely correction ensures refund eligibility is restored without unnecessary waiting periods.
Q. What happens if a defective return is not corrected within the deadline? If a defective return is not corrected within the permitted timeline, the return is considered invalid. An invalid return is treated as though it was never filed, meaning all associated benefits—refunds, deductions, and carry-forward losses—are denied. Additionally, the taxpayer may face late filing fees if the deadline for filing a fresh return has already passed. Although the Assessing Officer can condone delays in certain circumstances, relying on this discretion carries uncertainty. Correcting defects on time avoids these consequences.
Q. Can the Assessing Officer extend the 15-day deadline? The Assessing Officer has the authority to extend the 15-day response window based on the merits of the request. Valid reasons may include technical difficulties, portal access issues, incomplete financial data, or reliance on third-party documents such as bank statements or Form 16. Approval is discretionary and evaluated on a case-by-case basis. Submitting a well-documented extension request improves the chances of approval.
Q. Is revised ITR verification compulsory after correcting defects? Yes. Verification of the corrected return is mandatory for it to be considered valid. Even after uploading the corrected ITR in response to the defective notice, the process remains incomplete until verification is completed through Aadhaar OTP, EVC, net banking, or other accepted methods. Unverified corrected returns remain pending in the system, and processing—including refund issuance—will not proceed until verification is completed successfully.
Q. How does TaxBuddy simplify responding to Section 139(9) notices? TaxBuddy streamlines the defective return correction process by automatically identifying errors, mismatches, and missing information. It compares the filed ITR against AIS/TIS, Form 26AS, and the required schedules to pinpoint exactly what caused the defect. The platform then provides step-by-step guidance to correct the return, update bank details, select the correct ITR form, and fill in missing disclosures. Expert-reviewed filing ensures accuracy, reducing the risk of repeated defective notices. This makes TaxBuddy a reliable option for taxpayers looking to resolve Section 139(9) notices efficiently.
Comments