Why Freelancers Cannot Use Salary-Based Tax Planning Models
- Rajesh Kumar Kar
- 1 day ago
- 9 min read
Freelancers in India are often advised to use tax-saving strategies designed for salaried individuals, but this approach leads to incorrect filings and compliance risks. Under the Income Tax Act, freelance income is treated as profits from a business or profession, not salary. This single distinction changes how income is taxed, how deductions apply, and how returns are filed. Salary-based tax planning depends on employer structures like Form 16, fixed TDS, and predefined exemptions, none of which exist for freelancers. Applying these models to freelance income can result in mismatches, tax notices, or rejected returns.
Table of Contents
How Freelance Income Is Classified Under Income Tax Law
Under the Income Tax Act, 1961, freelance income is classified as profits and gains from business or profession. This classification falls under Section 28 and applies to individuals earning income independently without an employer–employee relationship. Unlike salary income, freelance earnings are not governed by Sections 15 to 17, which deal exclusively with employment-based compensation. This distinction determines how income is computed, which deductions are allowed, and which compliance rules apply. Freelancers are treated as self-employed professionals, making their tax treatment closer to business owners than salaried individuals.
Why Salary-Based Tax Planning Assumes an Employer Structure
Salary-based tax planning is built around the assumption that an employer exists to structure pay, deduct taxes, and provide benefits. It relies on components such as fixed monthly income, employer-managed TDS, Form 16, provident fund contributions, gratuity, and predefined exemptions. These elements simplify tax computation and reduce compliance for employees. Freelancers operate without this structure, meaning there is no automatic tax deduction, no employer-issued documents, and no predefined salary components to optimise through salary-based models.
Key Differences Between Salary Income and Freelance Business Income
Salary income is predictable, fixed, and supported by employer documentation. Freelance income is variable, client-driven, and self-reported. Salaried taxpayers depend on Form 16, while freelancers must maintain invoices, receipts, and books of accounts. Salary income is taxed after allowing standard deductions and exemptions, whereas freelance income is taxed after deducting actual or presumptive business expenses. These fundamental differences make salary-based planning unsuitable for freelance income.
Why Standard Salary Deductions Do Not Apply to Freelancers
The standard deduction available to salaried individuals is linked specifically to income classified under the head “Salary.” Freelancers do not fall under this head and therefore cannot claim this deduction. Instead of a flat deduction, freelancers are allowed to reduce taxable income by claiming legitimate business expenses incurred to earn that income. Applying salary deductions to freelance income can lead to incorrect computation and return defects.
Is Standard Deduction Allowed for Freelancers Under Any Tax Regime?
Standard deduction is not allowed for freelancers under either the old or the new tax regime because it is restricted to salary and pension income. Freelancers must choose between regular business taxation or presumptive taxation, depending on eligibility. Any attempt to claim the standard deduction against freelance income, regardless of the regime chosen, can result in denial during assessment.
How Business Expense Deductions Work for Freelancers
Freelancers are permitted to deduct expenses that are wholly and exclusively incurred for professional purposes. These may include internet charges, software subscriptions, office rent, depreciation on equipment, travel costs, and professional fees. Deductions are allowed under Section 37, provided proper documentation is maintained. Unlike salary exemptions, these deductions are not fixed and depend on actual usage and proportional allocation, making expense tracking essential.
How Section 44ADA Changes Tax Planning for Freelancers
Section 44ADA offers a presumptive taxation option for eligible professionals with gross receipts within the prescribed threshold. Under this scheme, 50 per cent of gross receipts are deemed as taxable income, and the remaining 50 per cent is treated as expenses. This simplifies compliance by removing the need to maintain detailed books. However, opting for this scheme restricts the ability to claim individual business expenses, which differs significantly from salary-based tax planning models.
Is Presumptive Taxation a Replacement for Salary Tax Planning?
Presumptive taxation is not a replacement for salary-based tax planning. It is a simplified business taxation method designed for self-employed professionals, not employees. Salary planning focuses on exemptions and allowances, while presumptive taxation focuses on deemed profit. The two operate on different legal principles and cannot be interchanged without risking incorrect filings.
Advance Tax Obligations Freelancers Must Handle Independently
Freelancers are responsible for paying advance tax if the total tax liability exceeds the prescribed limit in a financial year. Advance tax must be paid in quarterly instalments based on estimated income. Unlike salaried individuals, freelancers do not have employer-deducted TDS covering their tax liability. Failure to comply with advance tax provisions can result in interest liabilities, making proactive tax planning critical.
GST and Compliance Responsibilities Not Present in Salary Income
Freelancers may also be subject to GST registration and compliance depending on turnover and the nature of services. GST obligations include issuing tax invoices, filing periodic returns, and maintaining records. Salaried individuals do not face GST responsibilities, highlighting another reason salary-based tax planning frameworks are unsuitable for freelancers.
Why Salary-Based ITR Forms Cannot Be Used by Freelancers
ITR forms designed for salaried taxpayers assume income from salary and limited additional sources. Freelancers earning professional income cannot use these forms because they do not capture business receipts, expenses, or balance sheet details. Filing an incorrect ITR form can lead to defective returns and notices from the tax department.
How ITR-3 and ITR-4 Change the Filing Structure for Freelancers
Freelancers must file either ITR-3 or ITR-4, depending on whether presumptive taxation is opted for. These forms require disclosure of business income, expenses, assets, liabilities, and tax payments. This structure is fundamentally different from salary-based filing and demands a business-oriented approach to tax reporting.
Common Tax Errors When Freelancers Follow Salary Models
When freelancers apply salary-based tax planning approaches to professional income, several recurring errors tend to occur. These mistakes usually stem from misunderstanding how freelance income is taxed under business and professional income rules, rather than under salary provisions.
One of the most frequent errors is claiming deductions that are allowed only for salaried individuals. Freelancers often attempt to claim standard deduction, House Rent Allowance, Leave Travel Allowance, or other salary-linked exemptions. Since freelance income does not fall under the head “Salary,” these claims are not legally valid and can lead to disallowance during processing or assessment.
Another common issue is ignoring advance tax obligations. Salaried taxpayers rely on employer-deducted TDS to cover their tax liability, but freelancers must estimate income and pay tax in instalments during the year. When advance tax is missed or underpaid, interest gets automatically levied, increasing the overall tax outflow even if the return is otherwise accurate.
Using an incorrect ITR form is also a frequent consequence of following salary models. Freelancers sometimes file returns meant for salaried individuals because those forms appear simpler. However, these forms do not capture business receipts, expenses, or professional income details. Filing the wrong form can result in a defective return notice and force a revision within a limited time window.
Freelancers also tend to underreport or improperly disclose business income when applying salary-style thinking. Unlike salary income, which is fully reported through employer documents, freelance income must be aggregated from multiple clients, invoices, and bank credits. Missing or partial disclosure can trigger mismatches with reported TDS or bank transaction data.
Another mistake involves not claiming legitimate business expenses correctly. Some freelancers either skip expense deductions entirely or claim them without maintaining supporting documents. Salary-based planning does not require expense tracking, but freelance taxation depends heavily on accurate and justifiable expense records. Poor documentation weakens the claim if scrutiny arises.
There is also a tendency to misinterpret client-side TDS as final tax. Freelancers may assume that the tax deducted by clients fully settles their tax liability, similar to salary TDS. In reality, client TDS is only a credit against total tax payable, and any shortfall must be paid through advance tax or self-assessment tax.
Finally, following salary models often leads to overlooking GST-related obligations where applicable. Freelancers crossing prescribed turnover limits or providing taxable services may need GST registration and regular return filing. Salary-based planning ignores this entirely, increasing the risk of non-compliance and penalties.
Together, these errors raise the likelihood of interest liabilities, penalty proceedings, defective return notices, and scrutiny from the tax department. Freelancers benefit most when tax planning aligns with business income rules rather than employee-oriented frameworks.
How TaxBuddy Simplifies Freelance Tax Planning and Filing
TaxBuddy offers tools and expert support designed specifically for freelance and professional income. It assists with correct income classification, advance tax reminders, presumptive taxation evaluation, and accurate ITR-3 or ITR-4 filing. This structured approach helps freelancers stay compliant while optimising taxes within legal limits.
Conclusion
Freelancers operate under a business taxation framework that differs fundamentally from salary-based systems. Applying employee tax planning models to freelance income can lead to incorrect deductions, compliance gaps, and filing errors. Freelancers benefit most from tax strategies aligned with business income rules, presumptive options, and advance tax obligations. For anyone looking for assistance in tax filing, it is highly recommended to download the TaxBuddy mobile app for a simplified, secure, and hassle-free experience.
FAQs
Q. Does TaxBuddy offer both self-filing and expert-assisted plans for ITR filing, or only expert-assisted options?
TaxBuddy offers both self-filing and expert-assisted plans, allowing taxpayers to choose based on the complexity of their income. Individuals with straightforward income structures can use the self-filing option, which includes guided steps, validations, and automated checks. Freelancers and professionals with business income, GST exposure, or advance tax requirements can opt for expert-assisted plans, where qualified tax professionals handle classification, deductions, and filing to reduce errors and compliance risks.
Q. Which is the best site to file ITR?
The best site to file an income tax return depends on the nature of income and the level of support required. The official Income Tax Department portal is suitable for basic filings but requires taxpayers to understand form selection and tax rules independently. Authorised platforms like TaxBuddy provide structured workflows, built-in validations, and expert support, making them more suitable for freelancers, professionals, and individuals with complex income sources.
Q. Where to file an income tax return?
Income tax returns can be filed through the Income Tax Department’s e-filing portal or via authorised online tax filing platforms. Platforms such as TaxBuddy act as intermediaries that connect securely with the government portal while offering additional support such as error checks, reminders, and expert assistance. Filing through a compliant platform helps ensure correct form selection and timely submission.
Q. Can freelancers claim Section 80C deductions?
Yes, freelancers are eligible to claim deductions under Section 80C for qualifying investments such as life insurance premiums, ELSS, PPF, and certain fixed deposits. These deductions are claimed after calculating net business or professional income, not as salary-based adjustments. The eligibility and limits remain the same as for salaried individuals, but the computation flow differs because freelance income is taxed under business income provisions.
Q. Is HRA available to freelancers?
House Rent Allowance under salary provisions is not available to freelancers because it applies only to individuals receiving a salary from an employer. However, freelancers working from rented premises or home offices may claim proportionate rent and utility expenses as business deductions, provided the expenses are incurred wholly and exclusively for professional purposes and are properly documented.
Q. Is advance tax mandatory for freelancers?
Advance tax is mandatory for freelancers if the total tax liability for the financial year exceeds the prescribed threshold. Unlike salaried individuals, freelancers do not have employer-managed TDS covering their full tax liability. Advance tax must be paid in instalments based on estimated income, and failure to comply can result in interest liabilities. Regular monitoring of income and expenses is essential to avoid underpayment.
Q. Can freelancers use Form 16?
Form 16 is issued only by employers to employees and reflects salary income and TDS deducted. Freelancers cannot use Form 16 because their income is not classified as salary. Instead, freelancers rely on invoices, client payment records, and TDS certificates issued under professional sections, which must be reconciled while filing the return.
Q. Is presumptive taxation compulsory for freelancers?
Presumptive taxation is not compulsory for freelancers. It is an optional scheme available to eligible professionals who meet prescribed conditions. Under this scheme, a fixed percentage of gross receipts is treated as taxable income, simplifying compliance. Freelancers can choose regular taxation instead if actual expenses are higher or if they prefer detailed accounting.
Q. Can freelancers opt for the new tax regime?
Freelancers can opt for the new tax regime, but most business-related deductions and exemptions are not allowed under this regime. While the new regime offers lower slab rates, it may not be beneficial for freelancers who incur significant professional expenses. The choice should be made after comparing tax liability under both regimes based on the income structure.
Q. What happens if the wrong ITR form is filed?
If an incorrect ITR form is filed, the return may be marked as defective by the tax department. A notice is issued requiring correction within a specified period. Failure to rectify the defect can result in the return being treated as invalid, which may lead to penalties, interest, or loss of benefits such as refunds or carry-forward of losses.
Q. Do freelancers need to maintain books of accounts?
Freelancers are required to maintain books of accounts if they opt for regular taxation and cross the specified income or receipt limits. However, those opting for presumptive taxation under eligible provisions are generally exempt from maintaining detailed books, subject to conditions. Maintaining proper records is advisable even when not mandatory, as it supports accurate filing and future scrutiny.
Q. How can freelancers reduce compliance errors?
Freelancers can reduce compliance errors by maintaining proper documentation, tracking income and expenses regularly, paying advance tax on time, and selecting the correct ITR form. Using structured tax platforms like TaxBuddy helps automate calculations, flag inconsistencies, and guide users through correct filing processes, significantly reducing the risk of notices and penalties.
Comments