.png)
Futures and Options: Meaning, Difference Between F&O, Tax Implications, and Other Key Concerns
Understanding F&O Trading
F&O trading or FnO trading stands for futures and options trading and is a derivatives instrument linked to an asset called an underlying asset. This underlying asset can be of many types, such as equity shares, commodities, or currency (forex), hence making F&O trading diverse. It might be Equity F&O Trading, Commodity F&O Trading, or Currency F&O Trading (Forex Trading) as a form of it.
A trader agrees to buy or sell a contract on a specified date at a fixed time and price. On the other hand, Options Trading includes the contract on an asset between a buyer and seller on the exchange at a set price on a future date. And importantly, in Options Trading, the buyer can cancel the contract in the event of increasing losses, even at the price of a premium.
As regards futures and options traders, by the nature of their activity, they should indicate trading income in the section of Income Tax Returns.
What is Futures Trading?
Commitment in Futures Contracts: Futures contract involves a commitment or an obligation by two parties to consummate a predestined transaction at a future date.
Pre-agreed Price and Date: It is a commitment to buy or sell the underlying asset at a pre-agreed price along with a commitment for a pre-agreed date for carrying out the transaction.
Obligation Irrespective of Fluctuations: It is one characteristic feature of futures that relates to the fact that the commitment to fulfill the contract is there irrespective of market fluctuations.
What is Options Trading?
Rights Without Obligations: An option according to the trader goes on to give him the right, without at the same time imposing the obligation, to exercise the contract.
Flexibility of Option Holders: The holder, on the basis of the market condition, can make decisions to exercise his rights, giving advantages in handling strategic market moves.
Tailoring Actions to Market Dynamics: The unique flexibility of options allows investors to customize their actions in response to the evolving dynamics of the financial market.
Differences Between Futures and Options
Points of Distinction | Futures | Options |
|---|---|---|
Definition | Financial contracts with binding obligations. | Contracts provide the right (but not obligation) to buy/sell. |
Obligations | Both buyer and seller are obligated. | Only the seller is obligated; the buyer has a choice. |
Risk and Reward | Unlimited for both parties. | Buyer's risk is limited to premium; unlimited profit potential. The seller's risk is theoretically unlimited. |
Trading Flexibility | Standardized terms on organized exchanges. | More flexibility, customizable, traded on exchanges or OTC. |
Price Determination | Based on current market price adjusted for factors. | Influenced by market price, time to expiration, volatility, etc. |
Market Direction | Profits from both upward and downward movements. | Profits from upward, downward, or sideways movements. |
Who Should Opt For Futures and Options
Although this is the case, F&O trading can be suited to a variety of market participants. It is very important to note, however, that the instruments associated with F&O carry risks and complexities. The different categories of individuals or entities which might consider opting for futures and options include:
Experienced Traders and Investors:
Professional traders and investors, who understand the way financial markets function, are well-versed in technical analysis, and have a track record of good trading, will go for F&O to enhance the returns.
Hedgers:
Those businesses or investors who want to hedge against the fluctuations of the prices related to the underlying asset would use futures and options for risk management. A farmer who sells many acres of crops could use futures contracts in order to fix the price for crops which he expects to sell later.
Speculators:
F&O trading offers good returns for traders who are willing to take calculated risks and want to speculate on the future movements of prices.
Arbitrageurs:
Professionals who try to hedge against and make gains out of the existence of price differentials that may happen between related assets or markets by using F&O strategies.
Professional Portfolio Managers:
Professional portfolio managers may use F&O instruments to manage and optimize their investment portfolio with diverse strategies to generate higher returns or hedge them against market downturns.
The function of F&O instruments has, no doubt, been found in the hands of large institutional investors like mutual funds and hedge funds, providing them a useful means for an efficient managerial set-up of their exposure to different asset classes and also to put in place sophisticated trading strategies.
The Effects of F&O Transactions on Taxes:
a. Impact of F&O Transactions in ITR
The government treats the money you make from selling futures as the business's income. The gains (or losses) from futures and options will be taxed as business income, no matter if the trader is a paid worker, a business partner, or a pensioner. Because of this, the benefits will be added to the person's overall income and taxed at the standard slab rate. Remember that the return needs to be turned in by the due date, or it will be lost.
b. Reflecting Gains or Losses in ITR
The ITR has to represent any gains or losses from F&O transactions appropriately. The turnover used in tax computations is the absolute profit, taking into account both positive and negative fluctuations. To ascertain their tax burden, traders should disclose these numbers with diligence. For accurate reporting, it is essential to choose an ITR form, such as ITR-3, which is expressly meant for persons with business income.
c. Relevant ITR for F&O Transactions
Persons in the business of F&O trading have to avail the proper ITR form in such a case, as this happens to be ITR-3 meant for the declaration of business income. This helps in the proper declaration of the financial accounts in reference to F&O transactions, as per the need to make proper tax compliances towards the same.
d. Taxability of Different Investments in the F&O Segment
The taxability of different investments in the F&O segment, such as equity shares, commodities, and currency derivatives, is dependent on the particulars of the transactions. The correct way to report will depend on the tax implications of each kind of investment. Traders should consider things such as profit margins, turnover, and if they are subject to Section 44AB tax audits.
To conclude, it is incumbent upon people and organizations who intend to get engaged in F&O trading to bear in mind the complex tax ramifications of such deals. The income should be accurately declared in ITRs, the implication on tax payable should be understood, and the right ITR form should be filled. It would be advisable for people to consider using TaxBuddy or similar products that will not only enable them to sail through the tax complications arising out of F&O transactions but also provide approximations and suggestions to optimize financial planning.
Maintenance of Books of Accounts for F&O Transactions
In India, the requirement of maintenance of books of accounts of futures and options (F&O) trading transactions is governed by the rules as laid by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) and respective stock exchanges.
The main features related to the maintenance of books of accounts under futures and options trading transactions in India are:
1. Maintenance of Separate Books of Accounts: Trading members (stockbrokers) are to maintain separate books of accounts for the purposes of recording proprietary trades and client trades. The same would have to be maintained in accordance with the accounting standards prescribed by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI).
2. Client Ledger: The trading members shall maintain a separate ledger in respect of the transactions, receipts, and payments arising out of its trades on behalf of the respective client.
3. Contract Note: Contract notes have to be issued by the trading members to the clients against each trade executed, stating the specifications of the trade, brokerage charges and other charges applicable.
4. Bank records: Records of bank transactions relating to the dealings of the clients and bank transactions of proprietary may also include payment and receipt of margins, settlement obligations, and brokerage charges.
5. Trade Confirmations: The trading members shall maintain the records of the respective stock exchanges sent to them of the trade confirmations of the executed trades.
6. Risk Disclosure Documents: The trading members must keep the risk disclosure documents signed by the clients, confirming that the clients have understood the risks and taken their responsibility on their shoulders relating to the trading of futures and options.
7. Audit Trail: Appropriate audit trails shall be maintained by trading members for all orders placed, trades executed, and modifications or cancellations made with relevant timestamps.
8. Periodic Reporting: Besides these, the Trading Members are also to submit other reports and returns to the Stock Exchanges and SEBI from time to time, which also includes quarterly and annual financials, net worth certificates, and other regulatory reports.
9. Maintenance of Records: All books of accounts, records, and documents in relation to the transactions of futures and options trading shall be maintained for the minimum period as may be specified by SEBI and the respective stock exchanges, generally for a period of 5 to 8 years.
Conclusion
Finally, working in the tax laws and mechanics of trading in Futures and Options (F&O) involves knowledge regarding various issues like turnover calculations, which calculate gains in cash or capital form for different jurisdictions. Actual reporting requires the usage of the correct Income Tax Return form such as ITR-3. In conformity to Section 44AB, for one to meet the tax audit criteria on the basis of turnover and profit percentages, traders must be updated on the same. This calls for very careful comparison between the old and modern regime of tax because this affects tax to be deducted and loss carryforwards. Tools such as Tax Buddy enable you to compute tax smoothly and optimize your financial roadmap. TaxBuddy helps to simplify the complexities related to F&O trading for tax and stay compliant.
Frequently asked questions
Q
What does it mean to declare revenue from trading futures and options (F&O) using ITR-3?
A
Individuals and HUFs with non-speculative business revenue are the target audience for ITR-3. In compliance with tax regulations for non-speculative business activities, it guarantees proper reporting of financial records about F&O transactions.
Q
Is it possible to carry forward losses from trading Futures and Options (F&O) to counteract profits in the future?
A
You may carry forward non-speculative business losses from F&O trading for a maximum of eight years. Traders might lower their overall income tax liability by carefully offsetting these losses against future profits.
Q
What is the effect of the absolute profit formula on the turnover computation in F&O trading?
A
Turnover in F&O trading is calculated using the absolute profit formula, which takes both positive and negative changes into account. Even if tax obligation is unaffected by turnover, it is essential to figure out whether tax audits are applicable.
Q
What effects would the new Section 115BAC tax framework have on traders of futures and options (F&O)?
A
Slab rates under the new tax framework will be in effect until AY 2023–2024. Under this scheme, business losses cannot be carried forward by traders, nor can they be claimed as deductions under Chapter VI-A. Traders have the option to return to the previous system, but this should be well thought out.
Q
How can I find out whether my trading activity in Futures and Options (F&O) necessitates a tax audit?
A
A tax audit is necessary for turnovers up to two crores if the profit or loss is less than 6% of trade turnover. Nevertheless, regardless of profit or loss, no audit is necessary for turnovers between 2 and 10 crore.
Q
Can F&O traders migrate between the old and new tax regimes?
A
Yes, F&O traders can move between different tax regimes; but, once a new regime has been selected, there are limitations on going back to the previous one. It is advisable to weigh the effects of this choice on loss carryforwards and deductions.
Q
In the event of a tax audit, when are F&O traders required to submit their ITR?
A
The deadline for reporting taxes in tax audit cases is October 31st of the assessment year. F&O merchants must adhere to tax requirements by meeting this date.
Q
How does accurate reporting in futures and options (F&O) trading depend on selecting the appropriate ITR form?
A
Choosing the right ITR form, such as ITR-3, is vital for accurate reporting and compliance with tax laws connected to non-speculative commercial activities. It guarantees that bank accounts are correctly filed.
Q
What factors should F&O traders take into account most when choosing between the existing and new tax regimes?
A
When choosing between the old and new tax regimes, F&O traders should carefully analyze the impact on deductions, loss carryforwards, and overall taxes. Their tax responsibilities may be affected in the long run by this choice.
Q
Does trading in options include paying taxes?
A
F&O trading profits and losses must be recorded as business’s income. Tradesmen will thus pay taxes in accordance with the income tax slabs. This regulation does not, however, apply if investors make just two or three transactions in the course of the fiscal year.
Q
To whom is an income tax audit report required?
A
​An audit of tax returns is required of all businesses with a yearly turnover of more than 1 crore and of all professionals with income of more than 50 lakh rupees.
Q
How can F&O traders carefully balance their losses against their potential gains?
A
F&O traders might reduce their overall income tax liability by carefully offsetting non-speculative business losses against future profits. This may be accomplished by starting the offset in the current year and working your way forward.
Q
What are the F&O trading income slab rates under the previous tax system?
A
Under the previous tax system, the slab rates for income from foreign exchange trading ranged from NIL for revenue up to ₹250,000 to 30% for income above ₹15,000,000. Taxable income determines these rates.
Q
Do I have to pay tax on my F&O profits ahead of time?
A
If you have F&O income, it is considered non-speculative business income and is taxed at the standard slab rates. If you think you will make more than Rs 10,000 this financial year, you will need to pay advance tax in four equal payments, each due on the due date.
Q
For F&O dealers who opt for presumptive taxation under Section 44AD, how is advance tax computed?
A
By March 15th, F&O dealers opting for presumptive taxation under Section 44AD must pay the whole advance tax amount in one lump sum. This guarantees that F&O trading revenue complies with advance tax requirements.
Q
Do Futures and Options (F&O) traders have any exemptions from the tax audit requirements depending on turnover?
A
Tax audits are not necessary for turnovers between ₹2 -₹10 Crores, profit or loss notwithstanding. The reason for this anomaly is the extensive use of digital transactions—more than 95% of which utilize Demat.
Q
What effect does the absolute profit formula's flexibility have on the way trading turnover in F&O transactions is calculated?
A
Trading turnover may be calculated with flexibility thanks to the absolute profit formula, which takes into account both positive and negative changes. Accurate turnover estimates in the dynamic environment of F&O trading depend on this flexibility.
Q
​Can F&O traders make use of the new tax regime's Chapter VI-A deductions?
A
No, F&O merchants are not eligible to claim Chapter VI-A deductions under the new tax structure. A crucial component of the new tax system is this exclusion, and traders need to understand how it will affect their tax obligations.
Q
What effect does the new tax law have on the F&O trading industry's ability to carry forward business losses?
A
F&O merchants are not allowed to roll over business losses to future years under the new tax structure. This restriction, which has an impact on loss carryforwards and deductions, highlights how crucial it is to take the tax implications into account when selecting the tax structure.
Q
Is ITR-3 the sole form that applies, or may F&O traders choose various ITR forms depending on their trading preferences?
A
F&O traders are required to utilize ITR-3, which is intended exclusively for reporting business income while doing non-speculative operations. Selecting the appropriate form guarantees that financial accounts connected to F&O transactions are filed accurately.
Q
What are the requirements for conducting a tax audit under Section 44AB(e) and how does the computation of F&O turnover affect the application of tax audit?
A
F&O turnover is computed using the absolute profit formula. If the taxpayer has a profit or loss of less than 6% of trade turnover and has opted out of presumptive taxation in any of the previous five years, a tax audit under Section 44AB(e) is necessary.
Q
Are there any unique rules for F&O merchants that deal with advance tax payments, particularly for those who opt for Section 44AD's presumptive taxation?
A
By March 15th, F&O dealers who choose to be presumed to be taxable under Section 44AD must pay advance tax in one lump payment. By following this timetable, they may be confident that their F&O trading income tax responsibilities are fulfilled.