How TaxBuddy Handles Notice Chaos: A Breakdown by Section 139(9), 143(1), & 148
- Farheen Mukadam
- Aug 21
- 10 min read
Navigating the complexities of tax filing can be challenging, especially when it comes to understanding notices and assessments issued by the Income Tax Department. For taxpayers, receiving notices from the tax authorities can often cause confusion and anxiety. However, understanding the different types of notices and assessments, such as those under Sections 139(9), 143(1), 148, 142, and 143(2), is crucial to handling them effectively. Let us explore key notices issued by the Income Tax Department and explain what they mean for taxpayers. Additionally, we will discuss how TaxBuddy can streamline the process of responding to such notices, making tax compliance more straightforward and efficient.
Table of Contents
Understanding Section 139(9): Defective Return Notice
Section 139(9) of the Income Tax Act is an essential provision that addresses the issue of defective returns. When you file your Income Tax Return (ITR), the Income Tax Department scrutinizes the return to ensure that all the required information has been provided correctly and is in compliance with the applicable tax laws. If the Department identifies discrepancies, missing details, or errors in the return, it categorizes the return as "defective."
A defective return can occur due to a variety of reasons, including but not limited to:
Missing Mandatory Information: If crucial details such as your Permanent Account Number (PAN), address, or other personal information are missing, the return will be marked as defective.
Incorrect or Incomplete Financial Statements: If the financial statements, such as balance sheets, profit & loss accounts, or audit reports, are incorrectly filled or incomplete, the return will be considered defective.
Failure to Report Income or Exemptions: If you have failed to report income from certain sources or have not claimed allowable exemptions or deductions, the return can be considered defective.
Discrepancy in TDS (Tax Deducted at Source): A mismatch between the TDS details reflected in Form 26AS and the amounts claimed in the ITR can lead to a defective return notice.
Invalid Digital Signature or E-filing Issues: If you do not correctly sign the return or face issues during the e-filing process, it may lead to the Department classifying your return as defective.
Once the Department identifies these errors or omissions, they issue a notice under Section 139(9) of the Income Tax Act. This notice informs you that your return is defective and provides you with a specified period to correct the mistakes and re-submit the return. The notice typically contains a detailed list of the discrepancies or missing information that needs to be addressed.
Key Aspects of the Defective Return Notice under Section 139(9)
Issuance of Notice: A defective return notice is issued when the Income Tax Department determines that your ITR filing is incomplete or inaccurate. The notice specifies the errors or missing information and gives you a time frame to rectify the issue.
Rectification Timeframe: You are typically provided a time period to respond to the notice and correct the defects. The standard time given is 15 days from the date of receiving the notice, but this period can be extended in certain cases. It's crucial to take prompt action within the given timeframe to avoid further complications.
Mode of Rectification: You can correct the defects in your return by submitting the required details through an online portal or by filing a revised return. If the discrepancies are related to missing documents or incorrect information, you may need to submit the correct documents or amend the entries in your return.
Penalties for Non-Compliance: Failure to respond to a defective return notice within the given timeframe can lead to penalties, further scrutiny, and delays in the processing of your tax return. Additionally, the Income Tax Department may even disallow your claims for exemptions, deductions, or refunds if the issue is not addressed adequately.
Revised Return: If the defects cannot be rectified within the allowed time, you may be required to file a revised return. A revised return under Section 139(5) allows taxpayers to make corrections or changes to their originally filed return. However, this should be done carefully, as filing a revised return without correcting the underlying issues can lead to additional scrutiny.
Steps to Rectify a Defective Return
Review the Defective Return Notice: The first step is to carefully read the defective return notice issued by the Income Tax Department. This will outline the specific errors or missing details that need to be rectified. Ensure that you understand the nature of the problem before proceeding with corrections.
Gather Required Documents: If the defective return is due to missing documents or incorrect entries, gather the necessary information, such as correct income statements, tax credit certificates (Form 16), and other relevant financial documents.
Correct the Errors: Log in to the Income Tax e-filing portal and amend the defective return by filling in the correct information. Ensure that all mandatory fields are properly completed and that the correct TDS, exemptions, and deductions are claimed.
File a Revised Return (if necessary): If the errors are substantial or if you cannot simply correct the existing return, you may need to file a revised return under Section 139(5). This should be done carefully, as the revised return will supersede the original return.
Submit the Corrected Return: Once the necessary corrections are made, submit the revised return or rectify the errors through the online portal. Make sure you submit the corrected return within the stipulated time frame to avoid penalties or delays in refund processing.
Track the Status: After submitting the rectified return, regularly monitor the status of your filing on the Income Tax e-filing portal. If the defects are rectified satisfactorily, the return will be processed, and any refund will be issued as per the normal timeline.
Section 143(1): Intimation of Return Processing
Section 143(1) involves the initial processing of your ITR. After filing your return, the Income Tax Department processes it to verify the accuracy of the data provided. Section 143(1) provides an intimation or acknowledgment to the taxpayer, confirming whether their return has been processed successfully. The intimation will indicate if any discrepancies have been found, such as a mismatch in the tax calculation or any additional tax liability. If everything is in order, the intimation will confirm that the return has been processed, and any refund due will be issued.
Section 148: Income Escaped Assessment
Section 148 pertains to situations where the Income Tax Department believes that income has been understated or has escaped assessment. If the tax authorities suspect that a taxpayer has underreported their income or failed to disclose all relevant details, they can issue a notice under Section 148, known as an "Income Escaped Assessment." This notice typically arises when the Department identifies unreported income, such as income from foreign assets or unaccounted earnings. In such cases, the taxpayer is required to file a revised return or provide clarification to resolve the issue.
Section 142(1)/142(2A): Inquiry & Audit Notices
Section 142(1) gives the Income Tax Department the authority to issue an inquiry notice if additional information is required for processing the return. This notice may ask for specific documents or clarifications related to the filed return, such as income proofs, investment documents, or details regarding deductions. If the Department suspects discrepancies, it may issue a Section 142(2A) notice, which involves an audit of the taxpayer's financial records. Audit notices are typically issued when the Department wants to verify the accuracy of the information provided in the return. These notices often indicate a more thorough review of the taxpayer's financial affairs, requiring them to provide detailed records and explanations.
Section 143(2): Scrutiny Assessment
Section 143(2) deals with the scrutiny assessment process, which is initiated if the Income Tax Department believes that the taxpayer's return needs further investigation. This usually happens when there are significant discrepancies, unreported income, or incorrect deductions. A notice under Section 143(2) informs the taxpayer that their return will be scrutinized in greater detail. This assessment may involve a detailed review of the taxpayer's financial records, documents, and other relevant information. If any errors are found, the Department may issue additional demands or penalties.
Section 156 & 245: Demand and Adjustment Notices
Section 156 relates to notices regarding the demand for tax payments. If there is any outstanding tax liability, the Income Tax Department issues a notice under Section 156, informing the taxpayer of the amount they owe. This demand can be for taxes due based on the filed return or as a result of any assessments or audits. Additionally, Section 245 allows the Department to adjust any refunds due to the taxpayer against the outstanding demand. If there is a balance in the taxpayer’s favor, it will be refunded after adjusting the dues.
How TaxBuddy Streamlines the Process
TaxBuddy simplifies the process of dealing with these notices and assessments by providing an AI-powered platform that offers expert assistance at every step. If you receive any of these notices, TaxBuddy’s experts can help you understand the content of the notice, guide you on the necessary steps to take, and ensure that all required documents are submitted. The platform also offers tools to track the progress of your returns, manage notices, and ensure you stay compliant. TaxBuddy helps ensure that taxpayers don’t miss deadlines and avoid penalties by providing reminders and filing alerts.
Conclusion
Dealing with Income Tax notices and assessments can be a daunting task, but understanding the different types of notices and the procedures involved can make the process much smoother. With the help of TaxBuddy’s AI-driven platform, taxpayers can easily manage their returns, respond to notices, and stay compliant with tax regulations. By offering expert assistance and simplifying complex procedures, TaxBuddy ensures that the entire process of dealing with the Income Tax Department becomes more efficient and less stressful. For anyone looking for assistance in tax filing, it is highly recommended to download the TaxBuddy mobile app for a simplified, secure, and hassle-free experience.
FAQs
Q1: Does TaxBuddy offer both self-filing and expert-assisted plans for ITR filing, or only expert-assisted options?
Yes, TaxBuddy provides both self-filing and expert-assisted plans, offering flexibility to suit different filing needs. With the self-filing plan, users can file their ITR independently using the platform's guidance and tools. The expert-assisted plan connects you with experienced tax professionals who will manage the filing process for you, ensuring accuracy and compliance. This option is ideal for those who prefer to have a professional handle their tax filing or for more complex tax situations where expert assistance is crucial.
Q2: Which is the best site to file ITR?
The best site for filing your ITR depends on your requirements and preferences. The official Income Tax Department portal is the standard option for filing, but it may be complex for some users. TaxBuddy stands out as a top choice for many, offering a user-friendly platform that simplifies the filing process. With both self-filing tools and expert-assisted options, TaxBuddy ensures a seamless, error-free filing experience, helping taxpayers meet compliance deadlines with ease.
Q3: Where to file an income tax return?
Income tax returns can be filed on the official Income Tax Department portal at incometax.gov.in, or alternatively, through platforms like TaxBuddy. TaxBuddy simplifies the process with its easy-to-navigate interface, allowing users to file ITR accurately with minimal effort. It also offers expert assistance, making it an ideal choice for those seeking professional help.
Q4: Can I file my ITR after the deadline without penalties?
No, filing your ITR after the deadline results in penalties and interest. However, you can file a belated return up to December 31, 2025, for the FY 2024-25 (Assessment Year 2025-26). A penalty of up to ₹5,000 is applicable for belated filings, and interest will be charged on any unpaid taxes under sections 234A, 234B, and 234C of the Income Tax Act. Delayed filings can also cause a delay in refund processing.
Q5: What happens if I fail to file ITR within the extended deadline?
If you miss the extended deadline of September 15, 2025, you can still file a belated return by December 31, 2025. However, you will incur penalties for late filing, and your refund will be delayed. Filing after the deadline also means that your return will be processed after those who filed on time, further delaying any potential refunds.
Q6: How do I check the status of my income tax refund?
To check the status of your income tax refund, visit the official Income Tax Department e-filing portal and enter your PAN and assessment year details. Alternatively, if you filed through TaxBuddy, you can track the status directly on their platform or reach out to TaxBuddy’s support team for updates and assistance. TaxBuddy makes it easier to track your refund and resolve any issues quickly.
Q7: Does TaxBuddy assist with TDS credit verification?
Yes, TaxBuddy helps you verify TDS credits, ensuring they are correctly reflected in your return. TDS mismatches are a common cause of delays in refund processing, but with TaxBuddy, you can check if your TDS is accurately recorded before filing. This helps ensure a smoother filing process and minimizes the risk of delays in receiving your refund.
Q8: How long does it take for TaxBuddy to process an ITR filing?
TaxBuddy processes returns efficiently, with simple returns often completed within hours. If you opt for the expert-assisted plan, the processing time may take longer, depending on the complexity of your tax situation. However, TaxBuddy aims to ensure timely submission while maintaining accuracy, helping you meet deadlines and receive your refund faster.
Q9: What if I file ITR after the extended deadline?
If you file your ITR after the extended deadline of September 15, 2025, you can still submit a belated return until December 31, 2025. However, you will face penalties, and the processing of your return and refund will be delayed. Taxpayers who file late may also face additional scrutiny from the tax department.
Q10: Are there penalties for errors in my ITR filing?
Yes, errors in your ITR filing can result in penalties, interest on unpaid taxes, and delays in refund processing. Common mistakes, such as incorrect income reporting or missing deductions, can trigger penalties. TaxBuddy helps reduce the risk of errors with built-in error-checking tools, ensuring that your return is filed accurately and minimizing the chance of penalties.
Q11: Can I make corrections in my ITR after filing?
Yes, you can file a revised return if you notice mistakes after submitting your ITR. The revised return can be filed before the end of the assessment year, allowing you to correct errors like incorrect income or missed deductions. Filing a revised return helps ensure that your tax filing is accurate and helps avoid penalties.
Q12: Does TaxBuddy support all tax regimes for ITR filing?
Yes, TaxBuddy supports both the old and new tax regimes, allowing you to choose the one that maximizes your tax savings. The new tax regime offers lower tax rates but eliminates most deductions, while the old tax regime provides more deductions but has higher tax rates. TaxBuddy helps you select the best option based on your income, deductions, and financial goals, ensuring you pay the lowest tax possible while staying compliant.
Comments